Prime Video Hosts the World Premiere of The Rana Daggubati Show at the 55th International Film Festival of India

Prime Video hosted the World Premiere of its first-ever celebrity chat show, The Rana Daggubati Show, at the prestigious 55th International Film Festival of India (IFFI) on November 21. The first episode of the unscripted Telugu Original series, featuring Nani, Teja Sajja, and Priyanka Arul Mohan, received a remarkable reception from the audience present in the packed auditorium at the special screening, just days before its worldwide launch on the service.Prime Video Hosts the World Premiere of The Rana Daggubati Show at the 55th International Film Festival of IndiaThe World Premiere was attended by over 250 cinephiles, who were also treated to an interactive conversation with Rana as he delved into the series and shared insightful nuggets about his guests’ journeys in the world of entertainment. Also present at the screening along with Rana Daggubati were Sonal Kabi, Director & Head – Marketing, Prime Video, India, and esteemed dignitaries from the festival, including Smt. Shilpa Rao Tenugula – Director (Films), Ministry of I&B, Shri Tarun Talreja, GM – Production & Distribution at NFDC, Ministry of I&B, and Smt. Delilah Lobo – Vice Chairperson, Entertainment Society of Goa (ESG).The Rana Daggubati Show breaks the mould of conventional chat shows and gives the audience a tantalizing peek into the lives of their favorite stars. “Never imagined that The Rana Daggubati Show would be screened in front of such a lovely audience at the prestigious IFFI, at its 55th edition. We’ve changed the format of a talk show, removing the screen between the celebrities and fans. I’m grateful to Prime Video for being excellent partners. And I can’t wait for audiences across the world to watch the show when it launches on November 23,” said Rana Daggubati, host, creator, and executive producer of the show.Sonal Kabi, Director & Head—Marketing, Prime Video, India, said, “Audiences the world over have shown immense love and appreciation for the content on Prime Video, and we are continuing to push the envelope to cater to the different tastes and choices of the growing audience base. It is a matter of great pride to showcase our upcoming unscripted Telugu Original series at the 55th edition of the International Film Festival of India (IFFI), which is one of the most illustrious platforms for streaming services such as ours, as well as storytellers and actors from all over the globe to showcase their content. With The Rana Daggubati Show, we’ve completely flipped the format of a talk show. Rana’s unique, authentic perspective and incredible connections with celebrities bring a fresh and exciting dimension to the series, making it an unmissable watch.”The Rana Daggubati Show promises to feature a dazzling line-up of guests, including Nani, Dulquer Salmaan, Naga Chaitanya Akkineni, S.S. Rajamouli, Ram Gopal Varma, Rishab Shetty, Siddhu Jonnalagadda, Sreeleela, and many more celebrities over eight extremely entertaining episodes. With new episodes dropping every Saturday, The Rana Daggubati Show premieres on November 23, exclusively on Prime Video in India and over 240 countries and territories worldwide.Also Read: The Rana Daggubati Show: Baahubali actor promises to showcase unexplored side of celebrities in Prime Video’s unscripted Telugu original series.also-read{border-radius:10px;background:#f2f2f2;padding:10px 15px 0}.also-read .bx-wrapper{max-width:100% !important}.also-read h2{font-size:20px;margin-bottom:5px}.also-read ul{display:flex;-ms-flex-wrap:wrap;flex-wrap:wrap;position:relative;box-sizing:border-box}.also-read li{position:relative;flex:0 0 33.333333%;max-width:33.333333%;padding:0 5px}.also-read .imgsnb .imaginary img{border-radius:8px}.also-read h5{margin-top:10px}.also-read h5 a{color:#000 !important;font-weight:400;line-height:15px}#also-read .bx-controls-direction{display:none}@media only screen and (max-width:400px){.also-read li{width:31.10% !important}}.addformobile{display:none}@media only screen and (max-width:767px){.addformobile{display:block}}Tags : Amazon Prime Video, Chat Show, Features, IFFI, IFFI 2024, IFFI Goa 2024, International Film Festival of India, OTT, OTT Platform, Prime Video, Rana Daggubati, The Rana Daggubati Show, Web Show, World PremiereBOLLYWOOD NEWS – LIVE UPDATESCatch us for latest Bollywood News, New Bollywood Movies update, Box office collection, New Movies Release , Bollywood News Hindi, Entertainment News, Bollywood Live News Today & Upcoming Movies 2024 and stay updated with latest hindi movies only on Bollywood Hungama.

Children in need across Louth to receive the gift of a book this Christmas

Children in Louth receiving treatment in healthcare settings and children living in emergency accommodation and Direct Provision are among those who will receive a share of over 2,000 books this Christmas season, thanks to Children’s Books Ireland.
Launching their ‘Gift a Book’ appeal, the national charity is calling on the public for help to support children in need across the island of Ireland. Following the success of last year’s appeal which raised over €14,000 through generous public donations, Children’s Books Ireland is working with community groups and charities in Louth to deliver books to children in their services ahead of Christmas Day.  
Children of all ages will receive titles such as The Golden Hare by Paddy Donnelly and Milly McCarthy and the Christmas Calamity by Leona Forde and Karen Harte, which Children’s Books Ireland hope will ignite a life-long love of reading. 
Children’s Books Ireland CEO, Elaina Ryan, said: “Every child deserves the chance to become a reader and to find joy and comfort in a brilliant book. Together with our partners in charities and community groups in Louth, we can ensure that the children who need it most have a book to keep and call their own at Christmas.
“A book offers a world of possibilities! The gift of a book brings a much-needed moment of happiness, and we want to share that joy with every child in need. We are inundated with requests from charities across the country who want to bring the magic of Christmas to the children and families in their services. In launching this appeal, we want to help the thousands of children who still need our support.
“We are so grateful to everyone whose donations will help us to fulfil this Christmas wish. Help us to change children’s lives, one book at a time, by donating at www.childrensbooksireland.ie/giftabook.’
Along with providing children with a gift to unwrap on Christmas day, the gift will help children to develop a life-changing love of reading which will benefit them in a multitude of ways. Recent research carried out by the National Literary Trust in 2023 found that children who have books of their own read more often and, practice reading for joy. They also have improved reading ability and experience positive changes in behaviour, learning, and mental wellbeing. 
Similarly, an Irish study found that book giveaway programmes improved children’s ‘at home’ reading environment and helped them develop better reading skills. These positive outcomes, combined with a 15% increase in the number of children in Ireland entering emergency accommodation over the past year — where access to books and toys is often limited — highlight the critical importance of initiatives like the ‘Gift a Book’ appeal.
Niamh Randall, Director of Strategy and Public Affairs at Respond, one of the charities benefiting from the ‘Gift a Book’ appeal, said: “Respond is delighted to work with Children’s Books Ireland this Christmas and receive a generous donation of books for the children and young people throughout our services. Gifting a book to each child gives them the start they need to develop a life-long and impactful love of reading.
“Every festive season Respond staff work incredibly hard to make Christmas special for the children in our Family Homeless Services. We are grateful to Children’s Books Ireland for their support in ensuring that every child has a book to read and enjoy this Christmas.”
To donate or learn more about the ‘Gift a Book’ appeal, visit www.childrensbooksireland.ie/giftabook.

ADVERTISEMENT – CONTINUE READING BELOW

ADVERTISEMENT – CONTINUE READING BELOW

ADVERTISEMENT – CONTINUE READING BELOW

ADVERTISEMENT – CONTINUE READING BELOW

ADVERTISEMENT – CONTINUE READING BELOW

ADVERTISEMENT – CONTINUE READING BELOW

ADVERTISEMENT – CONTINUE READING BELOW

ADVERTISEMENT – CONTINUE READING BELOW

ADVERTISEMENT – CONTINUE READING BELOW

This Is the Year When Tourism in Israel Died. Where Do We Go From Here?

Masada is perhaps the most painful example, and also perfectly exemplifies the present situation. The clifftop site by the Dead Sea is enchanting at the highest international level. It features ancient royal palaces, stories of heroism, breathtaking views, and dozens of nearby hotels with spas – all in the lowest place in the world.
.htz-loader-circle{
-webkit-transform-origin:center center;
transform-origin:center center;
-webkit-animation:htz-loader-animation 1.5s infinite linear;
animation:htz-loader-animation 1.5s infinite linear
}
@-webkit-keyframes htz-loader-animation{
0%{
-webkit-transform:rotate(0);
transform:rotate(0)
}
100%{
-webkit-transform:rotate(-360deg);
transform:rotate(-360deg)
}
}
@keyframes htz-loader-animation{
0%{
-webkit-transform:rotate(0);
transform:rotate(0)
}
100%{
-webkit-transform:rotate(-360deg);
transform:rotate(-360deg)
}
}

Thanksgiving record travel expected for 2024

Thanksgiving TravelAdd TopicThe American Automobile Association (AAA) projects 79.9 million people will travel 50 miles or more from their home for Thanksgiving between Tuesday, Nov. 26, 2024, and Monday, Dec. 2, 2024, which is 1.7 million higher compared to last year and 2 million more than in 2019.Greg Lovett, Palm Beach Post Via USA TODAY NetworkAAA projects a record 71.7 million people will travel by car over Thanksgiving.Mario Tama, Getty ImagesLow gas prices are expected to fuel the record travel in 2024 as the national average could get below $3.00 for the first time since 2021.Michael Clubb, South Bend Tribune Via USA TODAY NetworkAAA projects a record 5.84 million people will fly domestically over Thanksgiving.Chip Somodevilla, Getty ImagesNearly 2.3 million people are expected to travel by other modes of transportation, including buses, cruises, and trains.Kevin Dietsch, Getty ImagesDomestic and international cruise bookings are up 20% in 2024 compared to last Thanksgiving.Martin Bernetti, AFP Via Getty ImagesThe worst times to travel by car over Thanksgiving are Tuesday, Nov. 26, 2024, and Wednesday, Nov. 27, 2024, in the afternoon.John Tlumacki, The Boston Globe Via Getty ImagesThe best time to drive to your destination for Thanksgiving is Thanksgiving Day itself.Jason Connolly, AFP Via Getty ImagesIf returning home from your Thanksgiving travel on Sunday, Dec. 1, drivers should leave in the morning. If returning home on Monday, Dec. 2, drivers should expect a mix of travelers and work commuters on the road between 9 a.m. and 6 p.m.Justin Sullivan, Getty ImagesAnd when it comes to the turkey, farmers raised 205 million turkeys in 2024, which is 6% less than last year, according to the USDA’s Turkeys Raised report.Lauren Witte, Clarion Ledger Via USA TODAY Network

Cuba: Tourism First, Housing Recovery Later

Photos: El Toque

By El Toque

HAVANA TIMES – The Cuban government has acknowledged that it will only be able to address 50% of the damage to roofs of homes caused by hurricanes Oscar and Rafael, as well as the earthquakes on November 10, 2024.

During a meeting on November 17, the Minister of Economy and Planning, Joaquin Alonso Vasquez, reminded that, in addition to the damages caused by these natural disasters, there are still cases of people affected by weather events in Pinar del Río (Hurricane Ian in 2022) and Guantánamo (Hurricane Matthew in 2017).

In contrast to the limited resources allocated to the repair of damaged homes, the tourism sector is recovering quickly, with the goal of being ready in the first days of December to receive tourists for the high season of 2024-2025.

This was confirmed by Juan Carlos García, the minister in charge of the Tourism who assured Granma newspaper that “the country and the Cuban economy” need the vitality of the hotel industry. Although he acknowledged that they will not meet the target of 3 million visitors in 2024, they are focusing their efforts and resources on improving services for tourists.

Fewer Tourists, More Hotel Investment

Although tourism in Cuba is practically the only one in the region that has not recovered since the 2019 pandemic, the government prioritizes what it calls “the engine of the economy.”

Despite the low occupancy rate – 28.4% in the first half of 2024 – resources have not been allocated to the recovery of other important sectors, such as agriculture or energy, nor to public services like health and education, despite daily reports of poor conditions in schools and hospitals.

Economist Pedro Monreal reported that “from 2020 to June 2024, investment primarily associated with tourism (the sum of ‘hotels and restaurants’ and ‘business services and real estate activity’) averaged 38.9% of the country’s total investment, compared to 9.4% for investment in electricity, gas, and water.”

The Canadian tour operator agency Sunwing, one of the largest sources of vacationers to Cuba, eliminated 26 hotels from its offerings on the island due to quality issues.

Samantha Taylor, the head of marketing, told Pax News that the hotels did not meet the expectations of what guests truly wanted to experience and acknowledged that prices had risen while quality had declined.

Regarding the loss of trust among Canadians in Cuban tourism, she mentioned that they had received cancellations and complaints from clients because the infrastructure did not meet expectations.

“What does a five-star hotel in Cuba mean? What’s to expect at a three-star hotel? What we see in our customers’ comments is that Canadians want transparency in what they are receiving. They don’t want surprises,” said Taylor.

Quality Issues Known to Cuban Authorities

Problems related to the quality of offerings are well known to Cuban authorities. Tourism minister Garcia stated that, to improve the conditions and services, “they created wholesale tourism provider companies, some of them with 100% foreign capital.”

Still, clients maintain questions regarding the quality of state-run tourist services, and some agencies suggest booking tours and trips through private businesses, which also guarantee electricity with generators and honestly explain to tourists what to expect from their trip and what they need to bring.

According to Travel Weekly, several agencies acknowledged that cancellations remain minimal but qualify the current moment as one of the worst for tourism on the island.

Recently, the Minister of Tourism  Juan Carlos Garcia told the Tass news agency that soon there will be hotels on the island built and managed by Russian companies, or others that will be managed by Russian entrepreneurs. Currently, there are 18 foreign hotel chains managing properties in Cuba.

It seems logical that the Cuban government would focus on Russian tourists (the second-largest source of visitors in 2024) when countries like Canada, France, or the UK advise their nationals not to visit the island due to power outages.

The promise of the marketing director of the Ministry of Tourism, Giana Galindo Henríquez, to guarantee backup generators for hotels is not enough. She told Tass that the impact of the nationwide blackout on October 18, 2024, was minimal in the sector, but it led to tourists being relocated to hotels with electricity service.

The Spanish  tourism-focused media outlet Preferente published that “tour operators, grouped in Seto, an industry  organization, have shown their absolute concern because telephone communications and the Internet network are very unstable.”

The report acknowledged that, despite government efforts, the recovery of normalcy in Cuba is no longer in the hands of the government.

One month after the first total blackout, Lessner Gomez, director of the Cuban Tourism Office in Toronto, assured that 100% of the hotel  facilities in Cuba had electricity.

Another point contrasting this information is that hospitals have suffered critical moments due to issues with their energy generators during extended power outages.

Homes vs. Hotels

According to preliminary data, more than 46,000 homes were affected by hurricanes Oscar (late October) and Rafael (early November), as well as the earthquakes on November 10, 2024. The majority of the damage was to the roofs of homes, and nearly 18% were total collapses.

While many of the affected people are currently living in tents donated by international organizations, the Cuban government is focusing on its 80,000 hotel rooms.

On several occasions, social media users have asked the government to use hotel facilities for the evacuation of people at risk due to natural disasters.

However, evacuations to the homes of friends and family are becoming more common. During Hurricane Oscar, for example, more than 70% of evacuations were carried out in the homes of acquaintances.

With blackouts lasting 12 hours or more across the country, homes with collapsed roofs, people who have lost almost everything due to natural disasters, and a population that takes to the streets every day to find food, the government is focused on attracting tourists and offering them new experiences.

The image in the cities is repeated: dark and impoverished streets, lit only by luxurious hotels that most Cubans cannot access.

First published in Spanish by El Toque and translated and posted in English by Havana Times.

Read more from Cuba here on Havana Times.

Cape Town CBD remains a good place for business

Retail, BPO, and financial sectors see surge in new businesses opening doors in 2023November marks National Entrepreneurship Month across the world, including in South Africa, an opportune time to spotlight how businesses, entrepreneurs, and small businesses contribute to the Cape Town economy.
Rob Kane, chairperson of the Cape Town Central City Improvement District (CCID) – Supplied by Boxwood Property Fund.
According to Rob Kane, chairperson of the Cape Town Central City Improvement District (CCID), as one of the most popular tourist destinations in the world, Cape Town and its CBD offer a dynamic economy for business investment and a fertile environment for innovation and entrepreneurship.
“The city centre, what Capetonians call ‘town’, is an excellent place in which to establish a business. Research shows that business is booming in the 1.6 km² area of the Cape Town CBD in which the CCID is mandated to provide services that enhance those offered by the City of Cape Town,” says Kane.
Citing data from the State of Cape Town Central City Report 2023: A Year in Review, the CCID’s award-winning annual report on the CBD economy, Kane reveals that the number of businesses that call the Central City home increased to 3 302, with 186 new businesses opening during 2023. Growth was experienced in 10 of the city’s 17 business sectors during 2023.
“Certain economic sectors flourished while others remained resilient in the face of economic headwinds,” he explains. “The ongoing renaissance of the CBD also saw growth and investment in its residential and commercial properties. This attracts more people to the city, benefiting inner-city businesses.”
One of the CBD’s dominant business sectors, the retail industry, increased its footprint by the broadest margin to 1 305 businesses, with 62 new retail outlets opening in the CBD during 2023.
A quarterly Business Confidence Index, conducted by the CCID, shows a rise in confidence, with most retailers satisfied with trading conditions in the CBD. Half of respondents believe that business activity has fully recovered from the pandemic, while 44 % say it has almost recovered.
During 2023, general corporates and head offices increased their presence in the Central City by 36 new businesses to total 108, while ICT, telecoms and call centres grew by 28 new entities to 106.  Cape Town’s CBD is favoured as an offshore business process outsourcing (BPO) destination, making up 42.9 % of the Western Cape’s BPO market.
Kane says: “The influx of BPO institutions has secured Cape Town’s status as the digitech hub of Africa and a leader in African BPO innovation. Along with government investment, the City of Cape Town is driving job creation through its strategic business partner, CapeBPO.”
In the CBD, the financial sector, including investment, insurance and banking, expanded from 171 entities in 2022 to 190 in 2023, with the Foreshore attracting most of this growth.
Another highlight from the report was the influx of 19 new artistic studios into the Central City during 2023, with 43 studios currently making their home in the CBD.
Says Kane: “There is a vibrant art culture in town, with many top tier galleries. In addition, it is the seat of the country’s Iziko South African National Gallery and the annual Investec Cape Town Art Fair, which is Africa’s largest art fair, attracts local, national and international visitors to the CBD.”
The CCID partners with the City of Cape Town and the South African Police Service (SAPS) to provide enhancing and supplementary services in the areas of safety, cleanliness and social development in its geographical footprint. It also promotes business and property investment in the Central City to ensure it retains its status as the most economically sound city centre in the country.
With its high occupancy rates, healthy property market, thriving economy and iconic beauty, Cape Town exemplifies what can be achieved through a successful private-public partnership.
“Given the Central City’s growing consumer base, coupled with a vibrant mix of retailers and businesses, successful trading conditions in the Central City, which have characterised 2024, look set to continue in 2025,” concludes Kane.

The new Bonhoeffer movie isn t just bad It s dangerous

Buried in the foreword to Project 2025’s “Mandate for Leadership,” the not-quite-disavowed blueprint for the incoming Trump administration, is a strange reference to Dietrich Bonhoeffer. “Open-borders activism,” the document declares, is “a classic example of what the German theologian Dietrich Bonhoeffer called ‘cheap grace.’” Bonhoeffer is then invoked to denounce other excesses of the left, such as environmental extremism and insufficient hostility to China.
It is obscene that an antifascist martyr’s memory is being used to legitimize a movement promising mass deportations, but the American right has long admired Bonhoeffer. Much of this admiration stems less from his theology than from his decision to join a conspiracy to assassinate Adolf Hitler—a decision that ultimately led to his execution in the Flossenbürg concentration camp. This has given rise to the dubious concept of the “Bonhoeffer moment,” a term some use to describe a historical situation in which nonviolence is no longer tenable for a Christian and something like his act of attempted tyrannicide becomes necessary. Bonhoeffer moments are imagined as moments of extraordinary moral clarity, when good and evil are laid bare and previously unjustifiable acts become justified.
It is this image of Bonhoeffer wielding righteous violence against a tyrannical state that has ignited the right’s imagination. In 2011, former VeggieTales writer and current far-right radio host Eric Metaxas’s Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Martyr, Prophet, Spy became a runaway hit and positioned him as a popular interpreter of Bonhoeffer’s legacy (see “Hijacking Bonhoeffer,” October 19, 2010). In 2020, he proclaimed that the allegedly stolen election marked a Bonhoeffer moment and that lethal force was now permissible to keep Donald Trump in power: “What’s right is right,” he said. “We need to fight to the death, to the last blood.”
But Bonhoeffer himself refused to see the plot to assassinate Hitler as morally justified. He insisted that what he was doing, while necessary, was at the same time a grave moral wrong for which he must repent and beg God’s forgiveness. In the hundreds of pages he wrote during his years in the conspiracy, Bonhoeffer adamantly warned that any sense of moral clarity we might feel is always an illusion. If we trick ourselves into thinking that we have full knowledge of good and evil, that we clearly see right and wrong, then we never have to question the moral purity of our actions. Because we are on the side of good against evil, we think that our actions—and our violence—must therefore be good.
This was the heart of Bonhoeffer’s theological critique of fascism: fascism seduces by promising knowledge of good and evil, shrouding its own violence in a fantasy of moral clarity. His greatest act of antifascist resistance is thus not some act of righteous violence but his own steadfast refusal to see even the most necessary and seemingly justifiable violence as a positive moral good.
The new movie Bonhoeffer adapts Metaxas’s biography for the big screen. It situates Bonhoeffer’s story in the familiar genre of the World War II thriller but erases the moral powerlessness and inescapable guilt that haunted him.
The real Bonhoeffer wrote that he felt lost in a “huge masquerade of evil” in which “evil appears in the form of light.” He lamented the uselessness of Christian ethics, which relies on “the abstract notion of an isolated individual who, wielding an absolute criterion of what is good in and of itself, chooses continually and exclusively between this clearly recognized good and an evil recognized with equal clarity.”
Bonhoeffer the movie, on the other hand, presents him as just this kind of moral agent who clearly recognizes good and evil, with the only real question being whether he has the stomach to do what he knows is right. By reducing moral deliberation to a question of will, the movie not only badly misreads Bonhoeffer. It also traffics in the dangerous idea of the Bonhoeffer moment, inviting its viewers to imagine that they, too, can clearly recognize evil tyrants in need of some justified violence.
Nearly every scene mangles and stretches both Bonhoeffer’s life and German history into a pat fable of good versus evil. The real Bonhoeffer’s bit part in the conspiracy to kill Hitler (using his church contacts in England to pass documents negotiating a possible peace treaty in the event the coup was successful, all of which were ignored) is transformed into a starring role, with Movie Bonhoeffer hunched over a table in the back of a bar, whispering about plans to construct a bomb. The real Bonhoeffer’s failure to radicalize German churches against Nazi antisemitism (a failure that informed his understanding of Christian ethics as a dead end) is in the movie a rousing success—the Confessing Church forms as an underground cell of Christian resistance under Bonhoeffer’s command, with one character gushing that “Bonhoeffer and his merry men” have “declared war on Hitler.”
The most egregious misreading of the real Bonhoeffer comes in a scene where he makes the fateful decision to join the conspiracy. His brother-in-law, Hans von Dohnanyi, has just told Bonhoeffer and his student Eberhard Bethge of the secret plan to kill Hitler. Bethge is shocked at the idea of committing murder and tries to talk Bonhoeffer out of it. He reminds Bonhoeffer that he once said Christians must defeat their enemies with the power of love. “That was before Hitler,” Bonhoeffer glowers. Bethge, despondent, asks, “Will God forgive us if we do this?” Bonhoeffer shouts him down: “Will he forgive us if we don’t?!”

The line gets Bonhoeffer’s thinking about the conspiracy exactly backwards. He was tortured by his decision to violate God’s clear and inviolable commandment not to kill. Everyone, without exception, is beloved of God, and killing is, in every situation, wrong. At the same time, it would be wrong to sit idly by as millions were murdered. No matter what he chose, whether he joined the conspiracy or not, he would be guilty. He had to act, he wrote, “in the sphere of relativity, completely shrouded in the twilight that the historical situation casts upon good and evil.” He joined the plot, but he refused to see his decision as morally justifiable. “Here the law is being broken, violated,” he deplored. It might be true that “the commandment is broken out of dire necessity,” but to say he broke the commandment of necessity is still to say he broke the commandment. Rather than pretend this was some positive moral good, Bonhoeffer instead threw himself at God’s feet and begged forgiveness for the sin he could not but commit. The movie has none of this squishy moral agony.
Bonhoeffer is clearly aware of the real Bonhoeffer’s writings on the impossibility of right moral action, but in the film any language of moral ambiguity is simply window dressing on a clear-cut case of good versus evil. Whenever Bonhoeffer does acknowledge the moral messiness of his actions, it’s always in tough-guy quips delivered like Clint Eastwood. When Dohnanyi tells him that the conspiracy will involve getting his hands dirty, Bonhoeffer snaps, “All I have are dirty hands.” And when he’s told he’ll have to swear an oath to Hitler so he can join the Abwehr and travel freely to England, he growls, “Sometimes you have to lie better than the Father of Lies.” Gone is the twilight of good and evil, gone is the diabolical masquerade in which evil appears as light.
This Bonhoeffer is exactly the kind of person the real Bonhoeffer skewered as an “ethical fanatic” who easily falls prey to fascism’s seductions. Ethical fanatics “believe they can face the power of evil with the purity of their will and their principles” but only end up “fall[ing] into the net of their more clever opponent” as their self-conception of being morally pure makes them blind to their own complicity.
I can’t help mentioning that Bonhoeffer not only is based on a far-right propagandist’s spurious biography but is produced by Angel Studios, which produced the QAnon-adjacent thriller Sound of Freedom in 2023. That film dramatizes the life of Tim Ballard, a self-styled crusader against child sex trafficking, whose bizarre claims that he led secret raids into African “baby factories” where children are harvested for Satanic rituals landed him on the first Trump administration’s anti-trafficking advisory board. (Ballard was removed from his organization after being accused by several women of sexual misconduct.) Ballard is played by Jim Caviezel, best known as Jesus in The Passion of the Christ and last seen at a Michael Flynn event at which the general endorsed the idea of a military dictatorship and Caviezel accused Hillary Clinton of consuming adrenochrome harvested from the blood of children.
Sound of Freedom and Bonhoeffer inhabit the same political and moral universe, in which the only moral dilemma is whether the good guys can set aside their squeamishness and start killing the bad guys. For the real Bonhoeffer, this was exactly the fantasy of moral purity that led so many into complicity with fascism’s escalating spiral of violence.
The final scene in Bonhoeffer, based on historically discredited accounts of the man’s death, explicitly invokes the idea of moral purity and extends it vicariously to the viewer. Bonhoeffer stoically marches to the gallows past his fellow prisoners (and the SS man whose heart, Grinch-like, grew three sizes after meeting the saintly pastor). He stands with the noose around his neck and recites the Beatitudes. When he gets to “Blessed are the pure in heart, for they will see God,” the camera cuts to the dappled sunlight shining through the clouds. As in every other scene, this is all text and no subtext: Bonhoeffer is pure of heart, and he has seen God.
But the real Bonhoeffer did not feel himself pure at heart. He felt himself an attempted murderer, wracked by shame and guilt, a moral failure whose only hope was in God’s boundless forgiveness. That his fellow conspirators saw themselves as heroes profoundly disturbed him. “We have been silent witnesses of evil deeds,” he wrote in a document circulated among the conspiracy. “Experience has rendered us suspicious of human beings, and often we have failed to speak to them a true and open word. Unbearable conflicts have worn us down or even made us cynical. Are we still of any use?” The film whitewashes the real Bonhoeffer’s crushing sense of uselessness, offering instead a Bonhoeffer who promises that violence can make us pure.
Project 2025’s invocation of Bonhoeffer to justify a regime of deportation and concentration camps is obviously absurd, but it illustrates the danger of remembering Bonhoeffer more for his decision to kill than for his insistence that no killing, even if absolutely necessary, can ever be justified. A truer way to think of a “Bonhoeffer moment,” instead of a moment when good and evil are laid bare and violence becomes permissible, would be a moment when we are so implicated in structures of evil and violence that right moral action becomes impossible and we cannot but choose wrongly.
In other words, every moment is this kind of Bonhoeffer moment.