click to enlarge
Courtesy of Parisa Taghizadeh | Warner Bros.
Beetlejuice Beetlejuice
Well, folks, this is the year Burlington lost its downtown movie theater — and the area’s only art house cinema. Merrill’s Roxy Cinemas closed in November, ending an era that dawned when I was still young enough to sneak into R-rated movies.
That’s actually one of my first memories of the theater at 220 College Street, then known as the Nickelodeon Cinemas 6. According to Cinema Treasures, the Nickelodeon opened in 1981 under independent ownership. (It would later belong to a couple of large chains before Merrill Jarvis II bought it in 2003.) In 1982, 14-year-old me brazenly purchased a ticket for An Officer and a Gentleman, which features full-frontal nudity. I guess it’s safe to admit that now?
Merrill’s Roxy Cinemas in Burlington to Close
Merrill’s Roxy Cinemas in Burlington to Close
By Mary Ann Lickteig
Theater
Like the Roxy to come, the Nickelodeon showed a mix of mainstream and art house fare, but it also screened classic and cult movies. Every month, I carefully perused the flyer detailing its program, which gave me an education in cinema history.
In 1983, my family stood in a line that stretched down the Nick’s brick façade on South Winooski Avenue to see Return of the Jedi. In 1985, I got nauseated during the early scenes of A Room With a View (from my lunch, not the movie), threw up in the tiny restroom and went right back and enjoyed the rest of the period piece.
Good Will Hunting, Boogie Nights, The Talented Mr. Ripley, Being John Malkovich, Notting Hill, The Blair Witch Project, American Psycho, The Ice Storm, Titanic, Capote, Sideways, The Royal Tenenbaums — all movies I first saw at the Nick/Roxy. Any local movie lover who’s been around long enough has a similar list.
Where will we see our indie films now? Perhaps at the Essex Cinemas or Majestic 10, if a movie has enough buzz to get on the program; perhaps at Vermont’s surviving art houses, such as Montpelier’s Savoy Theater and St. Johnsbury’s Catamount Arts; perhaps at a Vermont International Film Foundation screening. But not at Waitsfield’s Big Picture Theater, another casualty of the nationwide post-pandemic trend of theater closings.
Waitsfield’s Big Picture Theater & Café to Close
Waitsfield’s Big Picture Theater & Café to Close
By Mary Ann Lickteig
Film
Or maybe we’ll wait and catch those films streaming — because it’s hard to ignore the elephant in the living room: The audience for foreign and indie films skews older, and older people are more likely to stay home. No wonder original material is increasingly rare in multiplexes. So far this year, all but three of the 20 top-grossing theatrical releases have been sequels to previous hits — and one of those three, Wicked, could easily be mistaken for an Oz sequel.
We can only hope someone (or someones) steps up to fill greater Burlington’s art house gap. Meanwhile, a glance outside Vermont offers some encouraging signs.
In September, Variety reported that the nation’s eight biggest theater chains will collectively spend $2.2 billion on upgrades. The latest National Audience Survey from the independent theater coalition Art House Convergence showed an uptick in attendance, with the average new attendee being comparatively young at 38. And, according to a recent Associated Press story, young people are driving a renaissance of Los Angeles’ indie cinemas. Maybe that trend will make its way east.
In other good news, 2024 had no shortage of excellent theatrically released films, including many that weren’t sequels. Here are some movies that stood out for me this year. I’ve parenthetically noted which are on streaming services; look for the others in theaters or on VOD.
Breakout performance
When it comes to acting awards, smart money right now is on two relative newcomers: Mikey Madison, who plays a sex worker of many faces in Anora, and Karla Sofía Gascón of Jacques Audiard’s musical melodrama Emilia Pérez (Netflix), the first transgender actor to win Best Actress at the Cannes Film Festival. Both give memorable, larger-than-life performances.
There’s Plenty to Sing About in ‘Maria’ and ‘Emilia Pérez’
There’s Plenty to Sing About in ‘Maria’ and ‘Emilia Pérez’
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
But I’d like to draw your attention to Kani Kusruti, star of the Indian film All We Imagine as Light, which snagged the Grand Prix at Cannes and two Golden Globe Award nominations. In this naturalistic story of three working women’s lives in Mumbai, she brings revelatory nuance to her portrayal of a tired nurse with an absentee husband, who isn’t sure how to react to a doctor’s timid courtship.
Best film with a Vermont connection
Among the sequels that made bank this year was Beetlejuice Beetlejuice (Max, YouTube Primetime, rentable). For me, the fact that it was partially shot in East Corinth was the most interesting thing about it. (Second most interesting: the creative lengths to which Tim Burton went to include Jeffrey Jones’ character in the story without giving work to a convicted sex offender.)
With Scenes Shot in Vermont, ‘Beetlejuice Beetlejuice’ Embraces the Chaos
With Scenes Shot in Vermont, ‘Beetlejuice Beetlejuice’ Embraces the Chaos
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
For actual homegrown films, catch a screening of Bess O’Brien’s Just Getting By, a powerful documentary about unhoused Vermonters. Far Out: Life on and After the Commune continues to screen around the state to enthusiastic audiences. And Tommy Hyde’s Underdog, about a struggling Vermont dairy farmer who enters a dog-mushing competition in Alaska, is now streaming on Apple TV, Prime Video and Slamdance Channel.
Bess O’Brien’s Documentary ‘Just Getting By’ Puts Faces to the Problems of Housing and Food Insecurity in Vermont
Bess O’Brien’s Documentary ‘Just Getting By’ Puts Faces to the Problems of Housing and Food Insecurity in Vermont
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
Best first film
click to enlarge
Courtesy of Orion Pictures
Nickel Boys
India Donaldson and Annie Baker rightly made waves this year with their debut features, Good One (rentable) and Janet Planet (Max, rentable), respectively. Both are quietly provocative stories about girls coming of age in the woods and exploring the limits of their worlds.
A Father-Daughter Hike Becomes a Painful Coming of Age in ‘Good One’
A Father-Daughter Hike Becomes a Painful Coming of Age in ‘Good One’
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
RaMell Ross already had an acclaimed lyrical documentary (Hale County This Morning, This Evening) under his belt, but his stunning narrative debut, Nickel Boys, should take his career to another level. Based on Colson Whitehead’s novel about a Black teen (Ethan Herisse) who takes a ride in the wrong car and lands in a brutal reform school in 1960s Florida, the movie uses first-person perspective — a rare and risky choice — to bring us into the past with extraordinary intimacy. Look for it in theaters in January.
Indie Mother-Daughter Drama ‘Janet Planet’ Is Likably Down-to-Earth
Indie Mother-Daughter Drama ‘Janet Planet’ Is Likably Down-to-Earth
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
Most heart-rending animation
What is it that gives wordless animated films the potential to be so gut-wrenchingly sad? We Live in Time was a perfectly fine live-action weepie. But if you really want to cry over the pathos of human transience, watch Flow, a postapocalyptic animal adventure sans people, or Robot Dreams (Disney+, Hulu, rentable), the gentle friendmance of a dog and a robot in 1980s New York. You’ll never again be able to hear Earth, Wind & Fire’s “September” without misting up.
A Love Story Unfolds Out of Order in ‘We Live in Time’
A Love Story Unfolds Out of Order in ‘We Live in Time’
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
Most necessary sequel
The trippy complexity of the mythos behind Dune: Part Two (Max, rentable) justifies multiple films in my mind, but I still find it tough to care about Timothée Chalamet’s Paul Atreides as much as I do about the world around him.
The Plot Thickens and the Themes Darken in Space Epic ‘Dune: Part Two’
The Plot Thickens and the Themes Darken in Space Epic ‘Dune: Part Two’
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
As for the surprise hit Terrifier 3 (rentable), well, surely we can all agree that this year called for a blood-soaked killer clown Christmas movie.
Least necessary sequel
This is a crowded field, but for me, Glen Powell’s squinty charm and Marlboro man swagger failed to justify the existence of Twisters (Peacock, rentable).
Movie Review: ‘Twisters’
Movie Review: ‘Twisters’
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
Most effective bait-and-switch
Definitely not Joker: Folie à Deux (Max, rentable). To me, Todd Phillips’ musical sequel to his superhero-adjacent hit seemed perfectly consistent with its predecessor in its dour characterization and themes. But many fans of the original expected Arthur Fleck to rise from the ashes of Joker as, well, the Joker, and they certainly didn’t expect him to sing. The movie bombed with critics and audiences.
‘Joker: Folie à Deux’ Is the Fitting Sequel That Audiences Didn’t Want
‘Joker: Folie à Deux’ Is the Fitting Sequel That Audiences Didn’t Want
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
More successful at the box office (relative to its budget) was Alex Garland’s Civil War (Max, rentable), which left many moviegoers angry when it turned out to be about the ethics of wartime photojournalism and not about whom to root for if a civil war happened in the U.S. today. Personally, I don’t blame Garland for not sticking his hand in that hornets’ nest, and his images of a devastated heartland gave us all something to chew on.
Alex Garland’s Controversial Drama ‘Civil War’ Imagines a War-Torn America
Alex Garland’s Controversial Drama ‘Civil War’ Imagines a War-Torn America
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
Most old-school in a good way
click to enlarge
Courtesy of MGM
Challengers
If you skipped Luca Guadagnino’s Challengers (MGM+, Prime, rentable) because you don’t like tennis, give it a chance! This is the kind of movie Hollywood used to make all the time: a “grown-up” drama about smart, attractive professionals vying with each other for dominance in their field (and, yes, sometimes in the bedroom). It’s cleverly written, well acted, zippy and entertaining.
You Don’t Have to Be a Tennis Person to Savor the Court Intrigue of Luca Guadagnino’s ‘Challengers’
You Don’t Have to Be a Tennis Person to Savor the Court Intrigue of Luca Guadagnino’s ‘Challengers’
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
Most old-school in a bad way
I’m glad a movie about so-called “women’s issues” (which should be everyone’s issues) made so much money, but I can’t get behind the weirdly muted and gauzy treatment of domestic violence in It Ends With Us (Netflix, rentable). Blake Lively’s outfits shouldn’t be the focus here.
Best scenery chewing
click to enlarge
Courtesy of Kimberley French | A24
Heretic
There are good ways to chew the scenery! Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo both deliver big, big performances in Wicked while incorporating subtle touches that lend complexity to their archetypal characters. They deserve all the accolades they’re getting. Playing a faded star, Demi Moore goes big in The Substance (MUBI, rentable) and gives the best performance of her career.
Performances Soar in Overlong ‘Wicked’
Performances Soar in Overlong ‘Wicked’
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
Equally toothsome is Hugh Grant’s comic turn as a doddery, sweater-clad Heretic who can’t possibly have bad intentions when he invites two missionaries inside for a theological discussion … or can he?
Hugh Grant Plays a ‘Heretic’ in a Deftly Made Psychological Horror Film
Hugh Grant Plays a ‘Heretic’ in a Deftly Made Psychological Horror Film
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
Movies that might be honored here if I’d actually seen them
I have no excuse for missing Conclave, Sing Sing and A Different Man. But a bunch of other award contenders — including The Brutalist, A Complete Unknown, Nosferatu, Queer, Babygirl and I’m Still Here — haven’t screened in Vermont as of this writing. So take with this caveat my current choice of…
Best films
click to enlarge
Courtesy of Mubi
The Substance
Nickel Boys is one of those movies that you sink deeper into with each successive viewing. While the first-person approach is bound to have detractors, the film has the heft of an experimental literary epic — an absorbing, adventurous reflection on how we relate to our personal and collective pasts.
Other movies bowl you over and leave you gasping, like The Substance. Is Coralie Fargeat’s Hollywood horror tale for everyone? No! Does it have a ground-breaking message? No! But the unsubtle, comic maximalism of this movie captures the self-scrutiny and self-hatred at the core of a culture of images better than anything else I’ve seen. And that culture is where we live now, whether we like it or not.
Demi Moore Seeks Youth in ‘The Substance,’ a Boldly Satirical Horror Flick
Demi Moore Seeks Youth in ‘The Substance,’ a Boldly Satirical Horror Flick
By Margot Harrison
Movie+TV Reviews
The Substance is just one of the movies I’ll always be grateful to have seen on a big screen, with other people laughing, cringing and gasping around me. Happy New Year, and let’s celebrate the holidays by giving our local theaters some business.