Tough, world-traveling Miami woman’s murder devastated family, friends
Janet Acosta had a peaceful ritual during lunch breaks from her job at the Miami Herald. She’d drive to a quiet park next to the Japanese Rock Gardens, where she would sit her van under a shade tree while eating, napping and recharging.Michael Tanzi shattered that peace on April 25, 2000, when he attacked the 49-year-old Acosta, repeatedly punching her, tying her up and taking her on a nightmare four-hour odyssey that included her rape and eventual murder.When Acosta didn’t return to her job on the production staff at the Herald, her co-workers were concerned and a search was launched. Ultimately it was Tanzi who would lead police to where he buried her body over 100 miles away.Acosta was a world traveler who loved hiking and the outdoors, was so tough she once ran a marathon with a kidney infection and had a dog named Murphy Brown, her family said in court records obtained by USA TODAY.”Besides being my sister, she was my best friend,” her younger sister, Julie Andrew, testified. “We were very close.”Now, 25 years after Acosta’s murder, Florida is set to execute Tanzi by lethal injection on Tuesday.As his execution approaches, USA TODAY is looking back at who Acosta was and what made her special.Who was Janet Acosta?Acosta was the middle of three sisters: Joanie, Janet and Julie. Because their parents were alcoholics, Acosta all but raised her younger sister, Julie Andrew, according to Andrew’s testimony during Tanzi’s trial.“When we were children, we used to be awakened at night because my parents would be arguing and fighting,” she said. “Janet would hug me and we would hold on to each other until either we fell asleep or they quit arguing.”As adults, the three sisters remained close.”We used to e-mail every day and call. We’d call each other on the weekends and talk a couple hours,” Andrew said. “For some reason, we just never ran out of things to talk about.”Andrew described Acosta as a gentle soul, typically giving her dog Murphy Brown half her lunch and volunteering for Habitat for Humanity, which allowed her to meet former President Jimmy Carter.Andrew said that Acosta had a special bond with Andrew’s daughter, Jennifer.”She taught her how to fish. She encouraged her interest in art,” Andrew said. “She told Jennifer it was OK to be a tomboy and to be whoever you wanted to be.”Andrew recalled when the sisters needed to sell their childhood home. Andrew started crying as she looked at the house, and Acosta was there for her as always.”She walked over to me, she goes, What is this? And I said, ‘This has been home for over 40 years, and my mom’s now gone and we’re putting the house up for sale, and I feel like I’ve lost my home,” Andrew recalled. “And she just kind of looked at me and she put her arm around me and she said, ‘As long as you have family, you have a home.'”What happened to Janet Acosta?On April 25, 2000, Tanzi attacked Acosta while she was sitting in her car eating lunch, according to court records.He raped her 30 miles south of Miami in Florida City before continuing to drive south, forcing her to help him withdraw money using her ATM card. When they reached Cudjoe Key, about 20 miles shy of Key West, he strangled Acosta and buried her in a secluded place.Tanzi spent the next two days shopping, buying a new wardrobe, marijuana and food. Police officers arrested Tanzi after seeing him get into Acosta’s van in downtown Key West.Police recovered Acosta’s body after Tanzi confessed to the murder and showed them where he buried Acosta.Co-workers recall murder: ‘Something had happened to Janet’Robin Reiter-Faragalli worked at the Miami Herald as the vice president of human resources on the day that Acosta was murdered. In an interview with USA TODAY, she recalled how everyone knew something bad had happened when Acosta didn’t come back to work.“The mood at the Miami Herald from the get-go was very somber and dispirited,” Reiter-Faragalli told USA TODAY. “It was so out of character. Everybody had an intuitive, or innate sense, that something had happened to Janet.”In the days after the murder, Acosta’s coworkers described her as a friendly, creative person who would be dearly missed.Longtime co-worker Helen Lennon told the Miami Herald that Acosta had a big impact on her.“I have a bunch of teapots she made for me at home,” Lennon told the Herald at the time. “She was so friendly, creative. She has a great sense of humor.”Another co-worker, Carolyn Green, told the Herald that Acosta had given her the “gift of reading.”“She knew I didn’t like to read. So she’d tell me about a book until I got interested,” Green said. “I just can’t believe she’s gone.”Path to execution a ‘roller coaster ride’ for familyIn the years following Tanzi’s 2003 conviction, the Acosta family was left deeply scarred. Andrew told the Boston Herald in 2007 that the long process leading up to Tanzi’s eventual execution was a tough constant reminder of the murder.”Your life kind of goes on and you put it in the back of your mind, but then you get the call from the State Attorney’s Office, and it’s like a sledgehammer hits your chest,” Andrew said.In 2003, just after Tanzi was sentenced to death for Acosta’s murder, Andrew told the Herald why it was important for them to be at the trial and testify about Acosta.“Our whole reason for being here wasn’t for revenge,” she said. “We wanted to see justice done for my sister. And we wanted to make sure no one else had to go through what we went through.”Contributing: Amanda Lee Myers, Nick Penzenstadler, USA TODAYFernando Cervantes Jr. is a trending news reporter for USA TODAY. Reach him at fernando.cervantes@gannett.com and follow him on X @fern_cerv_.